From the Desk of the Interim Executive Director: Elections Have Consequences

Dan Bryant, Interim Executive Director, ShelterCare

Elections have consequences, and some of those consequences have a direct impact on the work we do here at ShelterCare. One of the consequences of the 2024 election was new leadership at HUD which does not support the concept known as “Housing First” (HF). HUD has been working for the past two years to shift federal dollars away from HF models to “Treatment First” models.

When these changes were first proposed in 2025, Jennifer DeVault, our former Executive Director, posted on the ShelterCare blog:

In 2006, ShelterCare was an early pioneer of the Housing First model, which is an evidence-based model that reduces barriers to accessing housing and has been proven to have effective, long-term results for ending homelessness. HF works on the premise that tenants have the same rights and responsibilities as any other renter, including a lease. The
model also works on the premise that tenants have voluntary access to supportive services, including case management and peer support. In a nutshell, HF believes individuals must meet their basic needs (i.e. shelter, food, water) before they can move on to other challenges, such as physical and mental health, sobriety, and employment.

ShelterCare’s PSH (Permanent Supportive Housing) program is not only vital to our community but is also one of our biggest programs, providing services to 111 people in our community. Of the 111 people served in the last year, only 6 exited to homelessness.

Two weeks ago, the federal government announced a shift away from housing first and permanent supported housing models to focus on transitional housing that centers on a treatment-first model.… By HUD’s own estimates, about 170,000 people across the country will be at risk of homelessness as a direct result of implementation.

Why this matters: This is a shift away from ShelterCare’s mission and values to provide services that are result-focused, evidence-based, trauma-informed, and person-centered. We believe that there is never a good time to abandon evidence-based practices to reduce homelessness, especially when it concerns our community members.

The first attempt by HUD to make the shift was successfully blocked by a lawsuit led by the National Alliance to End Homelessness which was joined by the State of Oregon. One of the complaints of that lawsuit was that HUD did not provide adequate notice of the change as required by law. The following year HUD provided the appropriate notification and then implemented their desired shift before reviewing the more than 900 comments made by groups like ShelterCare (available here). The result is that ShelterCare will have to shift away from its PSH program that depends on HUD dollars. In its place, ShelterCare plans to expand its Transitional Housing (TH) program. While the good news is that this will result in more beds to move people off the street, the bad news is that many of those currently in PSH will lose the services on which they depend and as a result, may end up back on the street. Broadly speaking, TH works best for those who are situationally unhoused whereas PSH is by far the best solution for those who are chronically homeless. The shift away from HF, therefore, will most likely result in more people who are chronically homeless. Increasing TH would be welcome, but defunding HF in order to fund more TH is a policy that will have drastic and ultimately cruel consequences for those who need that extra support.

Will the recent election and the change in Congress result in a return to funding that supports practices that are “result-focused, evidence-based, trauma-informed, and person-centered”? Time will tell but a couple of victory speeches on election night give me hope. One came from the Senator-elect in Kansas, Adam Hamilton, who happens to be a Methodist minister and thus spoke of uniting people around the “Golden Rule” to do for others as you wish others would do for you. The other was the Senator-elect from Texas, James Talarico, who spoke of the fight beyond politics that isn’t about differences between Republicans and Democrats, but the gulf between the top and the bottom. To bridge that gulf, Talarico called for a “politics of love” around which we can all unite.

Perhaps it is a little pollyannish to think federal policy can be based on love or the Golden Rule, but when it comes to vulnerable people on the street, I cannot help but think it would be a step in the right direction. Drop me line to share your thoughts!

Dan Bryant
dbryant@sheltercare.org

Leave a Reply

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close